data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/15254/1525451da7a4ee8cad7ba6a75e63c3b5d07a414f" alt=""
Review
The tobacco is dark brown with some yellow mottling, moist, cut into fragile 1 1/2" x 1" rectangles, and smells "malty" with a subtle sour hint. I rolled a few flakes into a tube and packed the tobacco into my pipe. The smoke is medium to rich in body with a subtle citrus tone and (thankfully) no trace of the McClelland ketchup. As the bowl progressed, I did notice the citrus subsided and a not unpleasant sour flavor emerged. I was expecting more spice but it is smooth and I experienced no tongue bite throughout the smoke. This flake burned evenly and slowly although I did have to re-light twice throughout the bowl. The ash is darker gray and the room note was present without overpowering.
Overall, this is a pleasant satisfying smoke that would be perfect for outside in the woods. The closest I can place this tobacco is either McClelland 2035 without the ketchup or MacBaren Roll Cake without a trace of topping or spice.
Rating: 4 Puffs out of 5
-Safari Bob
Hmmm...I love MacBaren Roll Cakes, so it sounds like I might well like this one. Thanks for the review!
ReplyDeleteComparing it to 2035, one of my favorites, had me wondering about the body of Astley's No. 44. I always assumed No. 44 was a fairly strong blend. I find 2035 a mild blend. I have a couple of tins in the back of my closet that have to be a couple years old now. I may open one fairly soon and find out for myself. Good review.
ReplyDelete